On this page
Every night Expado reads the career pages of more than 1,100 German employers. That raises a fair question, and people ask it: is that allowed? This is what we checked before building it, what we decided, and a few things we chose not to do even though we could have.
One thing first. I'm a software engineer, not a lawyer, and this is not legal advice. It's an honest account of how we think about it.
Why the employer's own page
A job ad is something an employer wants people to see. When a company publishes a role on its own career page, it has decided where that ad lives and who it's for: anyone looking for a job.
That's why we read the employer's page and not other job boards. A job board has put work into collecting ads, and that collection belongs to it. The employer's own page is the original. When you click a role on Expado, you land on that original page and apply there, the way the company intended.
The real legal question: the database right
In Europe there is a specific right that protects collections of data, not just creative work. If someone invested substantially in building a database, others may not copy a substantial part of it, or keep taking small parts of it again and again until it adds up to the same thing. In Germany that is § 87b of the Copyright Act.
For a service like ours, this is the line that matters most. It's the reason we read many employers' own pages rather than one big collection someone else built.
The source we turned down
The largest public job database in Germany belongs to the Federal Employment Agency. It has hundreds of thousands of ads, and its search runs on an interface that can be called from outside.
We looked at it closely and decided not to take ads from it. The interface was never published for outside services, the agency added a captcha in 2021 to slow down automated access, and the collection is exactly the kind of database the law above protects. It would have multiplied our numbers overnight. It wasn't worth it.
We do use it in one narrow way: to learn which companies are hiring, so we can find their own career pages. We keep the company's name, nothing else.
Being a polite visitor
- robots.txt. Every website can publish a file saying what automated visitors may read. On employers' own sites we follow it and skip anything it closes.
- One request a second. Many career pages run on the employer's own server. We read each of them at most once a second, at night, so we never get in the way of a real visitor.
- We say who we are. Every request carries our name, our website and an email address. If an employer wants us to stop, they can reach us, and we stop.
- Terms of service. We read the terms of the platforms companies use to publish jobs. One of them clearly forbids automated reading, so we removed every company on it, even though nobody had asked us to.
Personal data
Job ads sometimes name a recruiter with an email address or a phone number. We remove those before an ad is stored. Nobody needs a recruiter's mobile number in our database to find a job.
Your CV gets the same treatment. When you upload it, we take out your address, phone number, date of birth and similar details before anything else happens, and we delete the original file. What we keep is what the matching needs: your skills, roles and languages.
What we never do
We don't apply to jobs on your behalf. Tools that fire off applications in your name are easy to build and they look impressive, but an application is you speaking to an employer. Expado finds the roles, ranks them, helps with your documents and then gets out of the way. You press apply.
If you run one of those career pages
If your company's jobs appear on Expado and you'd rather they didn't, write to expadojobs@gmail.com and we'll take them out.
Sources
Figures checked against these official sources on .
- EU Database Directive 96/9/EC, Article 7 (the database right)
- German Copyright Act § 87b: rights of the database maker
- RFC 9309: the Robots Exclusion Protocol (robots.txt)
- General Data Protection Regulation (EU) 2016/679
- netzpolitik.org: the Federal Employment Agency and its job search interface (2021)
Expado reads your CV once and ranks every open role in Germany by how well it actually fits.
Get started free
